Of the three, I found Aloe to be the most refreshing. It genuinely felt like an explosion of freshness in my mouth which I didn't expect because I've tried out Aloe toothpaste in the past and none of them have blown me away as much as this one has. I have experienced a little bit of bleeding gums and some sensitivity and since using this variant, that has stopped and for that reason this variant gets a huge thumbs up from me. Another huge plus was the all-day clean feeling that it left me with. I kept running tongue over my teeth and loved the clean-feeling slip that this toothpaste had provided.